Does a $300 set of cookware cook better than $150 cooking pans? Not according to tests of nonstick and uncoated cookware conducted by consumer testing organizations like Consumer Reports.
What does cook better mean, anyway? Saucepans and other cooking pans “work” when they heat food evenly across the entire surface of the pan. Perhaps the single most important characteristic of good cook ware is the thickness of the bottom of the utensil. Thin bottoms burn food. A good pan simmers tomato sauce without hot spots bubbling hot liquid onto your hand and the cooktop. To see if your current cookware is up to snuff you should cook some pancakes in your favorite skillet. If they come out golden brown your cookware works. If the pancakes have uneven burn spots it’s time to upgrade your most important kitchen equipment. It’s no secret that quality cookware is one of the better gift ideas.
The Top Picks
Calphalon Commercial Hard Anodized 9-Piece Set

List Price: $492.00
Buy New: $159.99
You Save: $332.01 (67%)
Features:
• Set includes 8-, 10-, and 12-inch omelette; 3- and 7-quart covered chef’s casserole; and 2-1/2-quart covered shallow saucepan
• Heavy-gauge aluminum construction provides fast, even heating
• Domed metal lids seal flavors and nutrients in, plus evenly return moisture to foods
• Cool V handles stay comfortably cool for stovetop cooking
• Wash by hand recommended; metal utensil and broiler safe; lifetime warranty
Great pans February 22, 2008
I love the original Calphalon (as opposed to the new non-stick or OneInfused lines). I don’t think Calphalon makes the original any more, so I was glad to get this set (and the price was right, too).
Note: Calphalon isn’t for everyone. It doesn’t go in the dishwasher, and the pans are probably too heavy for people with limited hand/arm strength. Also, it’s not non-stick cookware (a plus in my opinion).
Other than that, I highly recommend these pans and plan to use this set for decades to come. Not only are they great to cook with, but they look good hanging from the pot rack, too.
First class cookware! February 15, 2008
If you want great quality cookware for an amazing price, look no further. The set includes everything you need to get started and it will last a life-time, I’m sure. I don’t have a problem with anything sticking. Heat your pans first before adding the oil and don’t use the spray oils on them! Always hand wash them (it’s not that hard). I can’t say enough good things about these. What a deal!!!
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless 10-Piece Cookware Set

List Price: $400.00
Buy New: $129.99
You Save: $270.01 (68%)
Features:
• Classic cookware made of mirror finish 18/10 stainless steel
• 8- and 10-inch skillets; 1-1/2- and 3-quart covered saucepans
• 3-1/2-quart saute pan; and 8-quart covered stockpot
• Solid, riveted handles, aluminum in base for even heating
• Safe for dishwasher, freezer, broiler, and oven to 550 degrees F
Sauteing wild salmon and stirring a perfect risotto take on spiritual dimensions with this classic Cuisinart cookware. Made of professional quality 18/10 stainless steel that won’t react with acidic foods, the pots and pans in this set feature solid cast handles, tight-fitting lids with drip-free rims, and a mirror finish that retains its brightness through dishwasher, freezer, broiler, and oven use up to 550 degrees Fahrenheit. For superior, even heating, an aluminum disk is encapsulated between two layers of stainless steel in each base. The set includes: 8- and 10-inch skillets, 1-1/2- and 3-quart covered saucepans, 3-1/2-quart covered saute pan, and a 8-quart covered stockpot. Cuisinart covers the set with a limited lifetime warranty. –Ann Bieri
A solid lasting set with fine performance March 17, 2008
This was my first purchase for pots and pans. After determining that it would be cost effective to buy a set and I’m also determined to start cooking more for myself, I choose this one after looking all over. I’m impressed after about 3 years of moderate to heavy use. Only one little problem with the rivets on the inner part of larger pan is becoming dislodged and food can be a little difficult to remove, but even this has not effected the performance of this pan.
It is fair to give this cooking set a solid 4.5 stars for price, lasting durability and a good performance. One more note that it scores well with me on even heat distribution. If they are a little difficult to clean I use a little dishwasher detergent and hot water.
Great Cookware set March 6, 2008
The Cuisinart stainless cookware set is beautiful. I really like them. They come out of the dishwasher sparkling! Pans heat quickly and evenly. Clean up is no problem. Soak while your eating dinner and then toss them in the dishwasher. I no longer eat specks of teflon from my previous non stick pans. My last set of pans - Cuisinart non stick were junk and cost more. The nonstick scratched easily, the exterior of the pans totally wore off after just a few washs. I was embarrassed to have those pans out on the stove. My new cookware set sparkles. Love them.
All-Clad LTD 10 Piece Cookware Set

Buy New: $680.95
All-Clad is the best and will last a lifetime. LTD looks great. This is a great set. February 12, 2008
My wife an I duked it out between Calphalon Commercial Nonstick (now called “Contemporary”) which she preferred for its lighter weight and All-Clad which I prefer for its tougher build. We have a bunch of each. The All-Clad stuff is better hands down. It heats quicker and more evenly. It seems to cook requiring lower stove temperatures. The anodized exterior is smoother and of higher quality. The clad stainless interior is exquisite and easy to clean.
This particular set is awesome - the most required pieces (6 Qt stock pot, 3 QT Saute, 2 QT Saucier, 8″ and 10″ fry pans, and 2 quart sauce pan). They constitute a complete kitchen set, lacking only, perhaps, a couple of larger pans (12″ fry and 5 Qt. Saute are really nice to have). The choice of stainless interior versus nonstick is personal - but I recommend the stainless interior. First of all, the stainless interior is virtually indestructible and will last a lifetime. All-Clad’s nonstick interior is the best in the business, but it does wear out. I’ve had several LTD nonstick pieces for 9 years now. The ones that get a lot of wear are starting to wear out. Nothing is more pathetic than a battleship built All-Clad pan with a frayed nonstick interior. It’s like putting fur in a truck bed. Nonstick might be easier to clean up - but the difference is trivial. Maybe you have the intention of cooking with less oil, but the difference between nonstick and LTD’s excellent mirror-like stainless interior is also trivial. I find the arguments for nonstick hard to defend.
As for the review that says anodized aluminum exteriors are hard to maintain, she should read the product literature. You clean anodized aluminum with a plastic scrubby (like the 3M green ones) with bleach cleanser (like Ajax or Comet). Just make a paste with the cleanser and power away stains in moments. Anodized aluminum - like all aluminum cannot be dish washed. The phosphates and brightening agents in dishwasher soap with create a chalky powdery rot in the anodized surface. If you are determined to dishwash your cookware you must forget about aluminum and stick to stainless steel. All-Clad makes a great like of stainless cookware - but nothing is prettier than LTD’s awesome black.
Anolon Advanced Nonstick Hard-Anodized Aluminum 10-Piece Cookware Set

List Price: $425.00
Buy New: $229.25
You Save: $195.75 (46%)
Features:
• 11-inch covered saute with helper handle, 1-1/2- and 3-quart covered saucepan, 8-quart covered stockpot, 8- and 10-inch open skillet
• Hard-anodized aluminum with Autograph nonstick coating inside and out
• SureGrip riveted handles constructed from stainless steel and silicone rubber
• Break-resistant, domed glass lids permit cooking to be easily monitored
• Oven-safe to 400 degrees F; limited lifetime warranty; hand wash
Coated inside and out with an Autograph nonstick coating, Anolon Advanced cookware provides heavyweight, professional-quality performance and 21st-century convenience. Pots and pans clean easily, while the rugged nonstick readily releases food. Beneath the nonstick is heavy-gauge, harder-than-steel anodized aluminum. Pot and pan bottoms are left uncoated to conduct heat quickly and prevent hot spots. Like many other Anolon cookware lines, Anolon Advanced features the company’s patented SureGrip handles, which are a combination of 18/10 stainless steel and silicone rubber and are riveted to the sides for durability. The ergonomic handles provide a comfortable, confident grip and stay cool on the stovetop for easy control. Break-resistant, domed glass lids permit cooking to be monitored without releasing heat and are oven-safe to 400 degrees F.
This 10-piece set outfits a kitchen with all essential pots and pans. It consists of an 11-inch covered saute with a helper handle, a 1-1/2- and 3-quart covered saucepan, an 8-quart covered stockpot, and an 8- and 10-inch open French skillet. The cookware carries a limited lifetime warranty against defects and should be hand washed. –Fred Brack
Love it!!! March 8, 2008
Best pan set I’ve ever owned. Heavy & the see through lids make it even better. The silicone handles make it easy to grip with a cool touch. I’ve already ordered extra pieces to complete my set. Highly reccomended.
love this set February 24, 2008
I just got this set about a month ago. I love it…heats well and clean up is a breeze. I ordered the 4 1/2 quart to go along with what came in the 10 piece set, so I have everything I need. I would highly recommend this product!
Lodge Logic Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron for Dummies Cookware Set

List Price: $90.99
Buy New: $58.49
You Save: $32.50 (36%)
Features:
• Includes 5-quart Dutch oven, 10-1/4-inch skillet, and high-temperature handle mitt
• Also includes Cooking for Dummies cookbook
• Cookware constructed of cast iron for superior heat retention and distribution
• Seasoned and ready to use out of the box
• Lifetime warranty
Includes 5qt. Pre-seasoned dutch oven,10-1/4in. Pre-seasoned skillet, 10-1/4in. Pre-seasoned cover, handle holder and cast iron cooking for dummies cookbook.
Great products, not so much the book August 4, 2007
I love these products but I don’t really use the book. It has alot of outdoors recipes, if that’s something that interests you.
Cast Iron package and cookbook is a good value January 18, 2007
The cast iron pan and dutch oven were high quality and pre-seasoned. The cookbook named “for dummies” was much more then expected. I would recommend this package to anyone.
Bialetti 9-pc. Cookset- Red Fusion

Buy New: $49.99
Features:
• Durable 9-pc. cookware set
• 100% aluminum
• Nonstick, easy-to-clean interior
Bialetti Fusion Style 8 Piece cooking set is “For the Melting Pot generation.” Cookware for the generation that’s merging Asian with Mexican, Thai with Southwest, creating new taste experiences and new cooking frontiers. 9 piece set includes - 1 qt saucepan with lid, 2 qt saucepan with lid, 5 qt dutch oven with lid, 8″ fry pan, 9.5″ fry pan, and a BONUS 11″ chicken fryer. Each piece has contoured stay-cool handles in matching colors, brilliant easy-clean exterior coating, aluminum bottom which disperses heat steadily and evenly, and a non-stick teflon interior. Color: Black, glass lids.
Good value for the money September 20, 2007
We’ve had a set like this (but in blue) for about four years, purchased for $60 in Target. While it is a good value for money and we used this set exclusively for three years, it has some weaknesses:
(a) Too light and easily deformed. The large pot fell to the floor and the lid would not fit anymore.
(b) The lids do not fit the frying pans, which is really odd